Jump to content
  • Greetings Guest!

    CheersandGears.com was founded in 2001 and is one of the oldest continuously operating automotive forums out there.  Come see why we have users who visit nearly every day for the past 16+ years. Signup is fast and free, or you can opt for a premium subscription to view the site ad-free.

Sign in to follow this  

Taxpayers are likely losers in first GM stock offering

Recommended Posts

Taxpayers are likely losers in first GM stock offering

12:17 PM

American taxpayers are likely to be losers when it comes to the first public offering of General Motors stock, Reuters is reporting.

Reuters, quoting six unnamed people, says the initial round is likely to be priced below what would be needed to put the the federal government on track to make a full recovery of the $50 billiion it sunk into GM last year to try to save it. But in later years, subsequent offerings may be priced at levels that would allow taxpayers to be fully paid back for saving the world's largest automaker.

The Treasury could take three years to sell down its remaining shares in GM, well into the next presidential term, and it would be years as well before taxpayers are made whole, if they ever are, on their investment, the news agency says.

GM recently announced that it would hold an initial public offering of stock, its first since bankruptcy reorganization. That would help the government get rid of some of its stake in GM, which has been derided as "government motors." Says Reuters:

But IPOs typically price at a discount of 10 percent to 15 percent to theoretical fair value to reward investors for taking a risk on a new issue and pave the way for future stock floats. In tough market conditions, that discount can be even larger.

"You have to sell people on the notion that there is an upside to what they are buying," one of the sources said.



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites


By Mark Kleis

Several sources familiar with the preparations of General Motors’ upcoming initial public offering are, according to the latest projections, suggesting that American taxpayers could take a loss on the offering, potentially pushing off payback for years.

The U.S. taxpayers currently lay claim to a 61 percent ownership stake in GM, meaning taxpayers would need GM’s IPO to value the automaker in the realm of $70 billion in order to break even on their investment. Six individuals with inside knowledge on the offering say that the Treasury intends to sell the first available shares below the projected break-even valuation rate, according to Reuters.

Selling shares below the market value is not a unique approach, Reuters points out that it is a common practice on Wall Street to give incentives to early investors. Typically the discount is placed between 10 and 15 percent, but some analysts are suggesting that GM may need to offer a deeper discount due to the looming economic uncertainty, increasing the likelihood that the taxpayers will not be fully reimbursed through the IPO.

Depending on the level of the discount, GM may come up short, as analysts believe that the market valuation of GM is between $50 and $90 billion – making the target value of $70 billion a possibility. Even if GM’s market value comes in at $70 billion, if the discount is too steep, the break-even will still not be met.

The sources also explained that for taxpayers to fully recoup the $50 billion investment made thus far, GM may need up to three years and several additional offerings.

Despite several projections placing a full payback out of reach at this time, GM still plans to hold a roadshow to woo investors beginning the day after the November 2nd elections, and leading up to the November 18th IPO.



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Taxpayers likely to face initial loss on General Motors IPO

September 7, 2010 - 12:01 am ET

NEW YORK (Reuters) -- The U.S. government is likely to take a loss on General Motors Co. in the first offering of the automaker's stock, six people familiar with preparations for the landmark IPO said.

Subsequent offerings of the government's holdings may be profitable depending on how investors trade the newly listed stock, the sources said.

But the question of whether taxpayers are ultimately made whole on GM's $50 billion bailout could be left open for years, the people said.

It could take more than three years for the Treasury to sell down its remaining stake in GM after the IPO, one person said. That would push a final accounting into the next presidential term.

A decision to price the initial GM shares below the cost to taxpayers would follow the usual Wall Street practice of giving the first investors in a new stock a discount, but it could also help allay investor concern in the face of the slow recovery of the U.S. economy and flat auto sales.

Post-election road show

Preparations for GM's IP0 remain confidential. Both GM and the U.S. Treasury have declined to comment, citing restrictions by U.S. securities regulators.

The Obama administration has pledged to exit its investment in GM as quickly as possible while holding out the prospect that taxpayers could ultimately be paid back in full.

Treasury spokesman Mark Paustenbach declined to comment. GM spokesman Tom Wilkinson also declined to comment.

GM plans to begin a roadshow for its IPO immediately after the November 2 U.S. midterm congressional elections, paving the way for a stock debut on November 18, sources have said.

GM in August filed paperwork for an IPO that could potentially be worth as much as $20 billion, making it one of the biggest IPOs of all time.

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is now reviewing the automaker's S-1 filing.

Analysts and potential investors have projected a market value for GM of between $50 billion to around $90 billion, based on projections for the automaker's cash flow, comparisons with rival Ford Motor Co and trading in bonds in the old GM which are convertible into shares in the new company.

A market value at the high end of that range would be above the roughly $70 billion in market capitalization that GM needs to achieve for the U.S. government to break even on its $43 billion remaining investment in the automaker.

But IPOs typically price at a discount of 10 percent to 15 percent to theoretical fair value to reward investors for taking a risk on a new issue and pave the way for future stock floats. In tough market conditions, that discount can be even larger.

"You have to sell people on the notion that there is an upside to what they are buying," one of the sources said.

Another of the sources said the discount could be as much as 20 percent on the GM IPO compared with the U.S. Treasury's break-even point.

Preparations for the GM stock offering remain in the early stages. A number of the sources cautioned that the size and value of the deal and the size of the stake to be sold by the U.S. government have not been determined and will not be set for weeks.

U.S. stake in 'Government Motors'

The U.S. government pumped $49.5 billion worth of taxpayer money into the automaker and took nearly 61 percent of its common stock.

GM has paid back $6.7 billion in debt to the Treasury and returned another $700 million in interest and dividends. The U.S. government also holds $2.1 billion in perpetual preferred shares in the automaker.

That leaves the government with a roughly $40 billion investment in the GM common stock that will debut in an IPO along with a new class of preferred shares that will convert into common shares under a mandatory provision.

In the days leading up to GM's August S-1 filing, Republican Senator Charles Grassley asked a special Treasury Department watchdog for an analysis of the GM IPO and how much money would be returned to taxpayers.

In its pitch to potential investors, GM will tout its global reach, recent gains in quality and pricing in its home market, and its sharply lower cost of operations after its 2009 bankruptcy, sources have said.

GM's $1.3 billion second-quarter profit was its biggest since 2004, when industry-wide U.S. sales were near 17 million vehicles compared with the 11.5 million sales rate of August.

But GM will have to address investor concern that growth in U.S. car sales in the second half of 2010 and into 2011 will likely be slower than analysts had expected just a few months ago.

At the same time, GM will have to confront a pension shortfall that remains a liability from its pre-bankruptcy operations.

GM eliminated about $40 billion in unsecured debt and other obligations in bankruptcy, but the automaker still needs to address a pension shortfall estimated at about $26 billion.

A successful IPO would be a political victory for the Obama administration and would help GM distance itself from critics who dubbed it "Government Motors" after its bailout.

Read more: http://www.autonews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20100907/OEM/100909941/1424#ixzz0ytaMUmqJ

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Your content will need to be approved by a moderator

You are commenting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

About us

CheersandGears.com - Founded 2001

We ♥ Cars

Get in touch

Follow us

Recent tweets



Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.