Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
William Maley

Industry News: There Is Such A Thing As Too Much Choice

Recommended Posts

Have you gone out and shopped for new vehicle recently? Are you overwhelmed by the variety of vehicles on offer? For example, if you decide to get a Porsche 911, you have the choice of 22 models. No, that isn't a misprint. Meanwhile other automakers have an array of models that carve out new niches and and mix existing body styles. Consider this, Audi sells 50 different variants around the world, a five-fold increase from the 90's when the German luxury automaker only sold 10 different variants. There has to be a point where automakers reach the point of too much and begin cutting back on their lineups, right?

PwC, a consulting firm tells Bloomberg that by 2018, some automakers will begin to level off their lineups. The reason for automakers leveling off their is increased costs in development and production, and better differentiate their offerings to consumers.

How bad is a large lineup for automakers? Detlef Kuhlmey, sales manager at Autohaus Kramm in Berlin tells Bloomberg that not many consumers get to see the full lineup because of how many choices there are.

“Carmakers look for something special to present,” Kuhlmey said. “To most customers it doesn’t really matter.”

Also trying to explain the small differences between the models adds a level confusion for dealers.

A case of automaker shrinking their lineup is PSA Peugeot Citroen. Europe's second-largest automaker is planning to cut back their global lineup from 45 to 26 vehicles by 2024 in a effort to return to profitability.

Others are going the opposite way. Mercedes-Benz is planning to add 11 new models by 2020.

“All these options reduce the likelihood that people will choose any, and reduce satisfaction when people do choose,” Lots of choices are helpful when people know what they’re looking for, but “in general, people don’t know exactly what they want,” said Barry Schwartz, the Swarthmore College social theory professor who wrote “The Paradox of Choice.”

Source: Bloomberg

William Maley is a staff writer for Cheers & Gears. He can be reached at william.maley@cheersandgears.com or you can follow him on twitter at @realmudmonster.

View full article

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

That is a major problem with today's industry.  Too few bodystyles per model.  Imagine this, just with the Chevy line:


Spark 3-door

Spark 5-door

Sonic 3-door

Sonic 4-door

Sonic 5-door

Cruze coupe

Cruze 5-door hatch

Cruze sedan

Cruze wagon

Malibu coupe

Malibu sedan

Impala coupe

Impala convertible

Impala sedan

Impala wagon


The Camaro and Corvette are properly represented, imo.

Edited by ocnblu

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it is a definition problem. Manufacturers would like you to believe that a different trim is a different model.  A body color grille and mirrors does not a new model make.  It's a trim of an existing model no matter how many "special edition" badges you put on it.   The last CTS had 6 "models" I'd say, Sedan/Coupe/Wagon and Sedan-V/ Coupe-V/Wagon-V 


Jeep has been doing the trimline=modelline thing lately... and I like what they are offering, but they are not models... they are trims. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Your content will need to be approved by a moderator

You are commenting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

    There are no registered users currently online

  • Social Stream

  • Similar Content

    • By William Maley
      Cadillac President Johan de Nysschen has a problem with the brand's dealers, specifically how many there are. According to data gathered by Autodata Corp and The Detroit News, Cadillac currently has 928 dealers in the U.S. A large number when compared to competitors in the luxury class such as Audi (281 dealers) and Mercedes-Benz (364). Factor in total sales for year and Cadillac finishes last with each dealer selling an average of 184 vehicles (170,750 vehicles sold for the year). This pales in comparison with the likes of Audi (648 vehicles sold last year per dealer) and Mercedes-Benz (978 vehicles sold last year per dealer).
      "With our very large dealer network … we so fragment the available volume, that many of our stores are unable to reach critical mass in terms of volume and their profitability to afford the investment in the kind of ... facilities that is the custom and practice for the sector," said de Nysschen.
      So what does de Nysschen plan to do about this? Well he isn't saying anything about cutting dealers at the moment. Instead, he is proposing smaller 'boutique' stores which will be separate facilities to have between 2 to 5 vehicles along with a virtual showroom with TV screens and 3-D images. The hope is that this will reduce a phenomenon de Nysschen calls "selling Cadillac out the back door of the Chevrolet store."
      "We want to create a concept that's built around the notion of a small boutique shop. The idea is you don't have to be a large, Taj Mahal mausoleum brand store to be classy and sophisticated and premium. You can do a small two-car showroom with an investment amount that is kind of appropriate to the size of the sales opportunity in their local market, and we harness technology to supplement then what we can offer," said de Nysschen.
      de Nysschen will be presenting this plan to dealers at the 2015 National Automobile Dealers Association conference in San Francisco this weekend.
      IHS Automotive analyst Tom Libby tells The Detroit News that de Nysschen's plan makes some sense as it allows Cadillac to build and grow a brand by separation.
      "It makes sense. It's a challenge to convince the retailer to invest a lot of money. It sounds like a compromise," Libby said of the idea.
      Source: The Detroit News

      View full article
    • By dfelt
      G. David Felt
      Staff Writer Alternative Energy - www.CheersandGears.com
      Faraday Future and Lucid Motors, Newest EV Automakers in America!
      Tesla as well as the Detroit, European and Asian auto companies have new competition. Tesla has seen in the last few years, engineers leave that had alternative dreams / plans that conflicted with Musk. As such this fall 2016 we are seeing coming out of the skunk works mode two new EV auto companies based in California is Farady Future who is already big in F1 E-Racing with over 1,400 employees world wide and Lucid Motors. Both companies have broken ground in Arizona for auto production lines. While there is little spec on motors, battery packs, etc. both companies using a rich background of Tesla Engineers clearly seems focused on building new Green auto's compared to waiting for Detroit to figure this out.
      Faraday has their F1 racer which also uses the same skateboard platform of which their concept driving around California is using. You can check out plenty of pictures online of heavily disguised CUV type EV.

      Lucid Motors also has their release pictures which includes their own camo covered auto's.

      For reading interest you can get more details on either of their web sites listed below.
      Lucid Motors
      Faraday Future
    • By dfelt
      Time for a new thread, I think many of us grew up seeing the various auto mags and the crazy Hot Rods that were totally custom rides from vans, to custom corvettes, etc.
      Post your cool find of Custom Ride.
      I will start by one that just blew my mind, talk about the perfect Van / Boat Hauler.
    • By dfelt
      G. David Felt
      Staff Writer Alternative Energy - www.CheersandGears.com
      Auto CEO Compensation
      CNBC with Reuters has posted CEO compensation for GM, FCA, and FORD for 2015 and clearly also points out GM CEO Barra's compensation jumps 72% to $28 Million for 2016.   2015 Compensation   GM CEO Barra - $7.3 Million on $152.4 Billion in sales, $10.8 EBIT earnings. FCA CEO Marchionne - $73.6 million  FORD CEO Field $18.6 million    Course stock does make up a large percentage of the pay package, but it is interesting to see what they are paid.   CNBC-Reuters story
    • By dfelt
      G. David Felt
      Staff Writer Alternative Energy - www.CheersandGears.com
      Apple Car Boom or Bust?
      So the question has to be asked of forum members, is this iCar a boom or bust for Apple and is this what the millennial crowd wants? Being that Apples biggest market is the millennial crowd I am wondering if this brick of a self driving electric auto is what they really want.
      Steve Jobs originally stated that Apple would work on an iCar and we ended up with this released drawing:

      Motor Trend had an exclusive first look at the iCar and this is what they ended up building:

      MT 13 Cool Features Story
      MT Industry Insiders Opine on Apple Car
      MT Apple Car Lie Down Till it Passes - Why they should NOT enter the auto industry.
      MT Apple Car Exclusive - Game Changer?
      MT Apple Car - But will you Love it?
      MT Tech Design experts Talk Apple

      What are your thoughts? Boom or Bust?
  • My Clubs

  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Reader Rides

About us

CheersandGears.com - Founded 2001

We ♥ Cars

Get in touch

Follow us

Recent tweets