OK, I decided not to sleep on it after all - so sue me.
I just sent Bob Lutz the following e-mail:
Mr. Lutz,
Two decades ago I purchased my first new vehicle, a 1987 El Camino SS. Ever since, I have been hoping to be able to do that again. In the 20 years since, I have purchased five new vehicles all of which have been either Chevrolets or Pontiacs.
I was overjoyed to learn of the release of the Holden VE Ute, and its likely export to North America. However, I am distressed at rumors of GM's intent to offer it as something other than a Chevrolet El Camino. I must urge you, in the strongest terms, to reconsider such a move. While I can see a certain amount of logic in offering the vehicle as a sibling of the Pontiac G8, or as a GMC Sprint/Caballero, I feel certain that this would be an awful mistake.
As a Pontiac, the advantages of commonality with the G8 would lend a sense of brand identity so desperately needed by that division. In addition, training of sales and service staff would be built-in. The VE Ute is a performer, and as such dovetails nicely with the intent of the Pontiac brand. As a GMC the Ute certainly fits, owing simply to its status as a truck and the history of the Sprint/Caballero. At GMC dealerships which also offer Pontiac, the commonality advantages would also apply, of course. However, I fear that as a Pontiac or GMC, the stunning VE Ute would only be a short-lived novelty product without staying power. Such a fine product deserves better.
The obvious alternative, of course, is to market the Ute as the Chevrolet El Camino we have all been anticipating for years now. 2009 marks the 50th anniversary of the El Camino, and a perfect opportunity to introduce a new model. No new Pontiac, nor re-issued GMC Caballero could hope to match the buzz a 50th anniversary El Camino could.
Imagine, if you would, the one-two punch as the new 2009 Camaro and El Camino grace the covers of magazines and the homepages of websites side-by-side. You can't buy that sort of exposure, it has to be part of your legacy. I'm asking that such an opportunity not be squandered, and that the VE Ute come to the US exclusively as the 2009 El Camino.
Respectfully,
Bob McQuiston (Camino LS6 on the boards)
Staff member: Cheers and Gears .com