Suaviloquent

Motortrend Comparison:A Taste of the Popular Midsize Luxury Crossover Offerings

3 posts in this topic

Suaviloquent    713

2016-Lexus-RX-350-F-Sport-Lincoln-MKX-AW

 

 

 

 

We gathered three likely 2016 midsize candidates: the redesigned Lexus RX 350 F Sport, the very originator of the segment itself and the first winner of MT’s SUV of the Year; the Lincoln MKX, a finalist in our 2016 SUV of the Year contest; and an all-new Mercedes-Benz GLC300 that replaces the boxy (and smaller) GLK-Class with handsome styling and a generous helping of the celebrated C-Class sedan’s hardware, interior treatment, and tech.

 

READ MORE AT:

 

http://www.motortrend.com/news/2016-lexus-rx-mercedes-benz-glc-lincoln-mkx-comparison/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Suaviloquent    713

This has been up for a while on their site. I'm sure many people have read it.

 

Interesting results. They also had a post script about the new XT5 and how it might have fared against these 3 cars, though one of them, the GLC seems out of place. The Lexus has poor interior packaging or form over function issues (gasp!), given the Lincoln has a good chunk more cargo space, but is shorter in length.

 

I did not expect the Lincoln to be an equal in ride sophistication to any Mercedes, given no air suspension, but it was. The interior comments are fair, but I disagree on the comfort of the seats, which again is preference more than anything. Also, the Sync 3 issue is rendered moot. The Lincoln MKX early build vehicles were Sync 2 (MFT), but later 2016 builds were quietly changed to Sync 3. Since the new setup has new hardware, the press vehicle could not be updated to Sync 3.

 

I think the Lincoln did well, the Mercedes has the edge in terms of interior quality in almost every price and size class. But the RX is pretty good still. I mean, there's a lot to like there, expect the mouse control setup.

 

We can speculate why the XT5 was not there, but it would've finished mid-pack.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
smk4565    321

An obvious result, as one of these companies builds the Best or Nothing, the other two dress up Camrys and Fusions.  

 

Similar price, but the GLC is a small vehicle, it is sized more like the NX250 and MKC.   I guess that would have been feeding the lambs to the the wolves, so they went with the MKX and RX350. 

 

What is amazing is the MKX Ecoboost with 380 lb-ft of torque could only manage 6.2 0-60 seconds while a 4-cylinder GLC could do it in 6.3 seconds.   I can't wait to see what the GLC43 does, with an extra 100 hp, it has to be in the low 5's.  Plus they have a V8 on the way, I'd like to see Lexus put a V8 in the RX, but they won't ever do that because they are S-A-W-F-T..... Saaaaaaaaaawft.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your content will need to be approved by a moderator

Guest
You are commenting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoticons maximum are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Similar Content

    • By William Maley
      Toyota Motor North America Reports U.S. Sales for July 2017, Sets New Record for RAV4
      More than 40,000 RAV4 sold for all-time record month Toyota, Lexus divisions post best-ever July light truck sales Lexus NX and Toyota Highlander post best-ever July PLANO, Texas, Aug. 1, 2017 /PRNewswire/ -- Toyota Motor North America (TMNA) Inc., today reported July 2017 sales of 222,057 units. With the one less selling day in July 2017 compared to July 2016, sales were up 3.6 percent on volume and up 7.8 percent on a daily selling rate (DSR) basis.
      Toyota division posted July sales of 193,155 units, up 3.6 percent on a volume basis, and up 7.8 percent on a DSR basis.
      "In July, Toyota division saw its strongest month of the year so far, and our second consecutive month of year-over-year increases based on sales volume," said Jack Hollis, group vice president and general manager, Toyota division. "We are thrilled to see RAV4 sales top 40,000 units in a single month – it is not only a milestone for us, but has set a new best-ever, all-time record monthly total. We continue to see momentum in the industry for light trucks, and are positioned well with strong availability of our SUVs. We are equally excited that the all-new 2018 Camry is receiving a strong reception as it started to hit dealer showrooms last week."
      Lexus posted July sales of 28,902 units, up 3.6 percent on a volume basis, and up 7.8 percent on a DSR basis.
      "Lexus utility vehicles had a stellar month, with a best-ever July for NX as well as the total LUV lineup, driving Lexus to its second-best July in history," said Jeff Bracken, Lexus group vice president and general manager. "We were also pleased to see strong ES sales in July, with sales up significantly over last year. We're looking forward to a robust August, with healthy inventory and the continuation of the Golden Opportunity Sales Event."
      July 2017 Highlights:
      Camry posts July sales of 33,827 units RAV4 posts sales of more than 41,800 units Highlander sales increased by 25 percent; posts new best-ever July 4Runner sales of 9,874 units in July Tacoma sales rise by nearly five percent in July Tundra posts July sales of 10,546 units Lexus posts second-best July in its history ES posts sales of 6,641 units for best July in a decade NX sets new best-ever July, up 15.3 percent LX up more than 14 percent in July RX sees 13 percent gain in July *Note: Unless otherwise stated, all figures reflect unadjusted raw sales volume
      TOYOTA  U.S. SALES SUMMARY
      JULY 2017
        -- CURRENT MONTH --
      -- CALENDAR YEAR TO DATE --     
                          2017
      2016
      DSR %
      VOL %
      2017
      2016
      DSR %
      VOL %
      TOTAL TOYOTA
      222,057
      214,270
      7.8
      3.6
      1,377,222
      1,412,072
      -1.9
      -2.5
      TOTAL TOYOTA DIV
      193,155
      186,380
      7.8
      3.6
      1,214,560
      1,232,618
      -0.9
      -1.5
      TOTAL LEXUS
      28,902
      27,890
      7.8
      3.6
      162,662
      179,454
      -8.8
      -9.4
                        YARIS IA (INCL SCI IA)
      3,333
      3,007
      15.3
      10.8
      22,081
      19,434
      14.3
      13.6
      YARIS LIFTBACK
      361
      794
      -52.7
      -54.5
      7,217
      7,378
      -1.6
      -2.2
      TOTAL YARIS
      3,694
      3,801
      1.1
      -2.8
      29,298
      26,812
      9.9
      9.3
      iQ
      0
      0
      0
      0
      0
      6
      -100
      -100
      xD
      0
      0
      0
      0
      0
      8
      -100
      -100
      xB
      0
      29
      -100
      -100
      0
      2,658
      -100
      -100
      tC
      7
      1,104
      -99.3
      -99.4
      181
      6,890
      -97.4
      -97.4
      COROLLA IM (INCL SCI IM)
      1,733
      1,601
      12.6
      8.2
      12,664
      10,682
      19.2
      18.6
      COROLLA SEDAN
      26,600
      31,717
      -12.8
      -16.1
      192,196
      213,910
      -9.6
      -10.2
      TOTAL COROLLA
      28,333
      33,318
      -11.6
      -15
      204,860
      224,592
      -8.3
      -8.8
      86 (INCL FR-S)
      655
      682
      -0.1
      -4
      4,391
      4,465
      -1.1
      -1.7
      MIRAI
      82
      52
      64
      57.7
      790
      270
      194.2
      192.6
      AVALON
      2,859
      3,754
      -20.8
      -23.8
      19,594
      27,069
      -27.2
      -27.6
      PRIUS
      9,384
      12,697
      -23.1
      -26.1
      64,484
      80,102
      -19
      -19.5
      CAMRY
      33,827
      34,123
      3.1
      -0.9
      210,724
      233,884
      -9.4
      -9.9
      TOTAL TOYOTA DIV. CAR
      78,841
      89,560
      -8.4
      -12
      534,322
      606,756
      -11.4
      -11.9
                        CT
      442
      849
      -45.9
      -47.9
      4,368
      5,364
      -18.1
      -18.6
      IS
      2,443
      3,461
      -26.6
      -29.4
      14,771
      20,560
      -27.8
      -28.2
      RC
      522
      977
      -44.4
      -46.6
      3,621
      6,269
      -41.9
      -42.2
      ES
      6,641
      5,497
      25.6
      20.8
      28,441
      33,390
      -14.3
      -14.8
      GS
      652
      1,218
      -44.3
      -46.5
      4,205
      8,670
      -51.2
      -51.5
      LS
      402
      433
      -3.4
      -7.2
      2,257
      3,311
      -31.4
      -31.8
      LC
      313
      0
      0
      0
      1,158
      0
      0
      0
      LFA
      1
      0
      0
      0
      1
      6
      -83.2
      -83.3
      TOTAL LEXUS CAR
      11,416
      12,435
      -4.5
      -8.2
      58,822
      77,570
      -23.7
      -24.2
      TOTAL TOYOTA CAR
      90,257
      101,995
      -8
      -11.5
      593,144
      684,326
      -12.8
      -13.3
                        SIENNA
      11,100
      11,734
      -1.6
      -5.4
      67,258
      79,959
      -15.4
      -15.9
      C-HR
      3,444
      0
      0
      0
      8,942
      0
      0
      0
      RAV4
      41,804
      31,886
      36.3
      31.1
      226,570
      197,786
      15.2
      14.6
      FJ CRUISER
      1
      2
      -48
      -50
      3
      8
      -62.3
      -62.5
      VENZA
      0
      20
      -100
      -100
      13
      563
      -97.7
      -97.7
      HIGHLANDER
      19,017
      15,213
      30
      25
      118,992
      97,142
      23.2
      22.5
      4RUNNER
      9,874
      9,599
      7
      2.9
      73,395
      64,067
      15.2
      14.6
      SEQUOIA
      963
      1,025
      -2.3
      -6
      7,174
      7,322
      -1.5
      -2
      LAND CRUISER
      193
      287
      -30.1
      -32.8
      1,725
      1,960
      -11.5
      -12
      TOTAL TOYOTA DIV. SUV
      75,296
      58,032
      34.9
      29.7
      436,814
      368,848
      19.1
      18.4
                        TACOMA
      17,372
      16,580
      9
      4.8
      111,968
      111,615
      0.9
      0.3
      TUNDRA
      10,546
      10,474
      4.7
      0.7
      64,198
      65,440
      -1.3
      -1.9
      TOTAL TOYOTA DIV. PICKUP
      27,918
      27,054
      7.3
      3.2
      176,166
      177,055
      0.1
      -0.5
      TOTAL TOYOTA DIV. TRUCK
      114,314
      96,820
      22.8
      18.1
      680,238
      625,862
      9.3
      8.7
                        NX
      5,406
      4,689
      19.9
      15.3
      31,429
      27,979
      13
      12.3
      RX
      9,632
      8,522
      17.5
      13
      56,369
      57,934
      -2.2
      -2.7
      GX
      2,075
      1,918
      12.5
      8.2
      12,972
      13,068
      -0.2
      -0.7
      LX
      373
      326
      19
      14.4
      3,070
      2,903
      6.4
      5.8
      TOTAL LEXUS TRUCK
      17,486
      15,455
      17.7
      13.1
      103,840
      101,884
      2.5
      1.9
      TOTAL TOYOTA TRUCK
      131,800
      112,275
      22.1
      17.4
      784,078
      727,746
      8.3
      7.7
      Selling Days
      25
      26
          177
      178
          DSR = Daily Selling Rate
         
    • By William Maley
      Equinox, Acadia, Envision and XT5 Achieve Best July Ever
      Crossover and trucks account for 80 percent of sales for best monthly mix ever July incentive spending as a percentage of ATP below industry average, driving ATPs up nearly $1,000 Commercial sales up 40 percent for best July since 2007 Lowest daily rental sales mix of any full-line automaker DETROIT — General Motors (NYSE: GM) today reported July U.S. retail sales of 202,220 vehicles, down about 14 percent from strong sales in July 2016. In July, GM’s crossovers and trucks account for 80 percent of sales for the company’s best monthly mix ever.
      While the U.S. market continues to moderate, sales of GM’s newest crossovers were strong in July:
      Chevrolet Equinox - up 4 percent for its best July ever. Chevrolet Bolt EV – 1,832 Bolts were sold in July for the best month ever. August will be the first month the Bolt EV is available on a national basis. GMC Acadia - up 30 percent for its best July ever. Buick Envision - up 89 percent for its best July ever. Cadillac XT5 - up 6 percent for its best July ever. GM’s July incentive spending as a percentage of average transaction prices (ATP) was 11.5 percent, more than 1 full percentage point below the industry average, and 0.5 percentage points below GM’s 2016 calendar year average. Some of GM’s competitors, without strong truck and crossover businesses, are offering significantly higher incentives across their entire portfolios, according to J.D. Power PIN estimates.
      In addition, GM’s ATPs were about $36,000, up nearly $1,000 from July 2016.
      “We have strategically decided to reduce car production rather than increase incentive spending or dump vehicles into daily rental fleets, like some of our competitors,” said Kurt McNeil, U.S. vice president of Sales Operations.  “We are working hard to protect the residual values of our new products and growing quality retail and commercial sales, and July’s ATPs reflect that discipline.”
      GM’s U.S. commercial vehicles sales were up 40 percent from last July, the best July since 2007, led by strong large van sales (up 89 percent), small utilities (up 61 percent) and large pickup sales (up 21 percent).  Year to date, GM commercial sales are up 11 percent. U.S. daily rental sales were down more than 11,200 vehicles or 81 percent in July, as planned. In July, GM’s daily rental sales accounted for only 1 percent of GM’s total sales.  GM continues to have the lowest U.S. rental mix of any full-line automaker at about 7 percent of total sales year to date.    
      GM’s July total sales were 226,107 vehicles, down about 15 percent from strong levels last year.
      “Changing customer tastes have driven us to refocus our business on higher margin, faster growing segments, like the crossover segments. We are launching the most all-new crossovers in our history to take full advantage of the changes occurring in the U.S. marketplace,” added McNeil. “Our newest crossovers are performing very well in the marketplace and we’ll build on that momentum with the all-new Chevrolet Traverse, GMC Terrain, Buick Enclave and the introduction of the Regal TourX through the second half of 2017.”
      By the end of 2017, GM will offer customers the U.S. industry’s newest and broadest lineup of crossovers.
      “U.S. auto sales continue to moderate from last year’s record pace, but key U.S. economic fundamentals remain supportive of strong vehicle sales,” said Mustafa Mohatarem, GM chief economist. “Under the current economic conditions, we anticipate the second half of 2017 will be much stronger than the first half.”
      July Brand Retail Highlights (vs. July 2016 unless noted)       
      Chevrolet
      Colorado was up 22 percent. Both Camaro and Cruze were up slightly. Crossovers best year to date: Equinox, Traverse and Trax. Volt has best year to date. Volt and Bolt EV July sales combined for more than 3,300 deliveries. Silverado LD double cab was up 4 percent. Buick
      Best year to date retail sales since 2005, up 2 percent. July ATPs are highest since December 2015. SUV mix is highest ever at 85 percent. GMC
      ATPs are the highest ever, up 8 percent from last July. Sierra boasts the highest ATPs in the full-size pickup segment. Sierra HDs up 6 percent in July and year to date up 9 percent, the best in a decade Yukon up 4 percent. Yukon had its best July since 2007. Cadillac
      CT6 up 7 percent. Year to date, XT5 retail sales are up 10 percent vs. combined SRX and XT5 sales a year ago. July ATPs up more than $3,000 and lead the luxury market and more than $3,000 higher than its closest competitor. Guidance on U.S. Vehicle Inventory Levels
      We anticipate we will end 2017 at or below last year’s level, with fewer cars and more trucks, crossovers and utilities in the mix. Pickup, crossovers and utility sales, GM’s strength, are expected to be stronger in the second half of 2017 vs. the first half of the year. We continue to monitor the marketplace and will make additional production adjustments if needed.
    • By William Maley
      Cadillac's sedan lineup in the future is going to look much smaller. Cadillac president Johan de Nysschen told Reuters in an interview that the ATS, CTS, and XTS will not be directly replaced when their lifecycles end in 2019. A new model called the CT5 will take their place and cost between $35,000 and $45,000.
      "We have to rebalance our sedan portfolio," de Nysschen.
      The CT6 will take care of the top end, while a new small luxury sedan (possibly named CT4) will handle the low end.
      de Nysschen reiterated plans of Cadillac building out their crossover lineup with the XT4 launching in 2019. de Nysschen also mentioned that Cadillac could be launching a range of electric vehicles in the latter half of the next decade.
      Source: Reuters

      View full article
    • By William Maley
      Cadillac's sedan lineup in the future is going to look much smaller. Cadillac president Johan de Nysschen told Reuters in an interview that the ATS, CTS, and XTS will not be directly replaced when their lifecycles end in 2019. A new model called the CT5 will take their place and cost between $35,000 and $45,000.
      "We have to rebalance our sedan portfolio," de Nysschen.
      The CT6 will take care of the top end, while a new small luxury sedan (possibly named CT4) will handle the low end.
      de Nysschen reiterated plans of Cadillac building out their crossover lineup with the XT4 launching in 2019. de Nysschen also mentioned that Cadillac could be launching a range of electric vehicles in the latter half of the next decade.
      Source: Reuters
  • My Clubs

  • Who's Online (See full list)

    There are no registered users currently online