I can't quite bring myself to vote in this poll because the issues at hand are far too muddy.
I have some very definite ideas about what should become of Pontiac in general and GTO specifically. Most of which are consistent with the premise outlined by Griffon. However, I will restrict myself to the problems I see with this notion for the balance of this post.
Problem #1 : Names. The G6,G4,G8 nomenclature is entirely bankrupt and should be tossed.
Problem #2: Camaro. Without specifics of what platform will underpin our favorite new Chevy, we don't have all the information we need to come up with a sensible plan for any Pontiacs related to the Camaro. Unless the Camaro platform is a shortened and modified version the same Zeta/Sigma2/Zegma architecture as other forthcoming RWD models a la the Holden model, I can't see GTO sharing its underpinings. I don't think that GTO and Camaro should be so close that they share wheelbases and overall shape and size. That route would lead to either a bad Camaro or a bad GTO. They should never be the twins that Camaro/Firebird were. Which brings me to the brutally honest part of this problem. I love the GTO and long ago faced the fact that we can't have both the GTO and a new Firebird. That said, if the two have to be very close in size and shape and wheelbase the Pontiac in question should be called Firebird not GTO. I don't want to see this happen- but it makes sense. I'd rather see the Camaro stand alone in wheelbase and sheetmetal and ride on a shorter version of the same RWD platform used for the GTO and other RWD cars.
Problem#3: Timing: The G6 is still very early in its life cycle and the GTO needs to be ready very soon. So, what are we talking about here? Moving the G6 name to a GTO based sedan model? (see problem#1) Or are we just saying that a RWD sedan (call it Tempest or Lemans) needs to accompany a Camaro twin? (see problem#2)
One point of agreement with this whole idea: I too, believe that Pontiac should move toward an all RWD/AWD lineup sooner rather than later with one exception. That exception would be the Vibe which could remain FWD with a healthy dose of performance and compact cool. Think Mini and you will see what I am thinking.