cp-the-nerd

C&D: Lincoln MKZ 3.0T AWD First Test

42 posts in this topic

cp-the-nerd    426

http://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2017-lincoln-mkz-30t-awd-test-review

Zero to 60 mph: 4.8 sec
Zero to 100 mph: 12.0 sec
Rolling start, 5-60 mph: 5.5 sec
Standing ¼-mile: 13.4 sec @ 105 mph
Top speed (governor limited): 150 mph
Braking, 70-0 mph: 156 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad*: 0.93 g
EPA: 17/26 mpg
Curb weight: 4307 lb
As Tested: $59,975 (base price: $43,735)


There's so much to break down in this review, because the numbers tell so little of the story. Like the Fusion Sport, the engine is the car's greatest asset. Hit the gas and it gives serious thrust, though it's connected to an aging 6-speed automatic. Looking at the test results with no context, this seems to be just a hair behind the Audi A6 3.0T, which would be an excellent achievement, but as you read through the driving impressions things look less rosy. Fitted with the mind boggling selection of Michelin Pilot Super Sport tires (meant for dedicated high performance cars), the .93g of recorded grip was overkill for the FWD-based chassis.

"...Worst of all, after cornering, the whole car wags like the tail of a Newfoundland puppy that just discovered freeze-dried chicken jerky. It then takes some time to recover its composure. And the all-wheel-drive system isn’t able to keep up, either, as the MKZ still wants to torque-steer off the road.

...these are summer-only sports-car tires fitted to a car tuned for all-season touring rubber. In fact, the placard in the doorjamb of our test car gave away the fact that it started life without these tires—the placard listed a different tire size than those fitted to the car—which Lincoln reps no doubt swapped in hope of improving test numbers.

One gets the sense that these tires were specially chosen for vehicles that would see performance testing by the media. According to Lincoln’s online configurator for the 2017 MKZ, the optional summer tire will be a 245/40R-19 (just like the Michelins on our test car); although the Lincoln website doesn’t specify the tire brand or model, it’s hard to imagine dealers ordering high-performance rubber for this car."

In the end, this car would have likely found greater fanfare with the high-end all season touring tires that it was engineered for. Let the luxury and impressive 400 horsepower engine speak for themselves without trying to be some sort of poseur sport sedan. This also leads us to the other elephant in the room: $59,975 as tested. That's the cost of a Fusion Sport and a Fusion Hybrid combined... for a car based on the Fusion.

Personally, I'm FAR from sold on Lincoln's latest direction, and this review only cements the impression of confused luxury goals and engineering compromises.

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ccap41    1,163

I think it looks great from the front (I like the Jag look even though it is a knockoff design), Terrible back end, and  "meh" center stack.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
dfelt    1,782

:palm: Not even sure where to begin on this, ccap summed it up pretty good.

Meh!

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cp-the-nerd    426

It's not that they're ringer tires, it's that they don't belong on this car from an engineering standpoint. These are michelin pilot super sports. They're made for Porsches, Corvettes, and V-series Cadillacs. The review illustrates pretty clearly that the suspension reaches its limit before the tires do.

If you put super sports on a Toyota Corolla, it would probably hold .9g and brake shorter too.

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Wings4Life(BANNED)    1,000,000

The MKZ with 3.0L and 200A trim package, including upgraded 19” wheels I just built has an MSRP sticker of $39,345 and comes nicely equipped.  I can’t think of ANY luxury maker anywhere that can touch all that for the price.  I dare anyone to try.

 

The ‘ringer’ tire argument is lame and I seriously doubt they put tires on the vehicle that are not available.  Personally, I think Lincoln should have used the standard tires, perpetuating their smooth, quiet thrust narrative, or whatever they call it.  Low profile tires in a luxury sedan is a waste. Today’s cars perform excellent as is, so there was no need to get that extra little bite in a car like this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, dfelt said:

:palm: Not even sure where to begin on this, ccap summed it up pretty good.

Meh!

You forgot at least one face palm.

 

11 hours ago, cp-the-nerd said:

It's not that they're ringer tires, it's that they don't belong on this car from an engineering standpoint. These are michelin pilot super sports. They're made for Porsches, Corvettes, and V-series Cadillacs. The review illustrates pretty clearly that the suspension reaches its limit before the tires do.

If you put super sports on a Toyota Corolla, it would probably hold .9g and brake shorter too.

Sport Compact car, and I think Road and track did just that.  Corolla was pretty good with those tires...but still no sports sedan.  Same for the Lincoln.

2 hours ago, Wings4Life said:

The MKZ with 3.0L and 200A trim package, including upgraded 19” wheels I just built has an MSRP sticker of $39,345 and comes nicely equipped.  I can’t think of ANY luxury maker anywhere that can touch all that for the price.  I dare anyone to try.

 

 

 

The ‘ringer’ tire argument is lame and I seriously doubt they put tires on the vehicle that are not available.  Personally, I think Lincoln should have used the standard tires, perpetuating their smooth, quiet thrust narrative, or whatever they call it.  Low profile tires in a luxury sedan is a waste. Today’s cars perform excellent as is, so there was no need to get that extra little bite in a car like this.

 

Personally, I would be buying a Lexus IS series and calling it done with this price range. The only reason I would stop in my local Lincoln dealer with this in the showroom would be to get a free cup of coffee and shoot the bull about Ohio State Football.

In all honestly the modern Acura lineup is as ugly as home made sin from the front, but the chassis on Acura's are much more nimble than pretty much anything Lincoln builds.

Lincoln will never re gain its spot as an aspiration automaker, something it has not had since the Beetles all played together and we were about to take one small step for man and one giant leap for mankind.

Really, honestly, cannot tell you how quick this would go in for a trade in if it were in my driveway. But then I am not really a luxury car kind of guy anyways. 

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Wings4Life said:

The MKZ with 3.0L and 200A trim package, including upgraded 19” wheels I just built has an MSRP sticker of $39,345 and comes nicely equipped.  I can’t think of ANY luxury maker anywhere that can touch all that for the price.  I dare anyone to try.

 

 

 

The ‘ringer’ tire argument is lame and I seriously doubt they put tires on the vehicle that are not available.  Personally, I think Lincoln should have used the standard tires, perpetuating their smooth, quiet thrust narrative, or whatever they call it.  Low profile tires in a luxury sedan is a waste. Today’s cars perform excellent as is, so there was no need to get that extra little bite in a car like this.

 

And I also agree with your logic here.  People are not running these at your local autocross or doing track days in them, they are picking up their kids from middle school and taking their spouse to a basketball game.  All sticky tires will do on a car like this is infuriate owners when they have to replace them at 12,000 miles.

 

People got angry with the Honda S2000, STI WRX, and Mitsu Evo for having to replace tires after 12,000 miles...what will peoples reaction be with a car like this?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cp-the-nerd    426
2 hours ago, Wings4Life said:

The MKZ with 3.0L and 200A trim package, including upgraded 19” wheels I just built has an MSRP sticker of $39,345 and comes nicely equipped.  I can’t think of ANY luxury maker anywhere that can touch all that for the price.  I dare anyone to try.

 

The ‘ringer’ tire argument is lame and I seriously doubt they put tires on the vehicle that are not available.  Personally, I think Lincoln should have used the standard tires, perpetuating their smooth, quiet thrust narrative, or whatever they call it.  Low profile tires in a luxury sedan is a waste. Today’s cars perform excellent as is, so there was no need to get that extra little bite in a car like this.

 


Base MSRP for a 3.0T AWD is $43,735. This is included in the C&D specs I posted and confirmed on Lincoln's website. They shouldn't even offer that engine with FWD, which is what you used (along with incentives) to get it under $40k.

The tire argument is lame to *YOU* because you refuse to see the reality of Car & Driver's comments or anyone else's perspective, for that matter. Ford sent that car--insane options and all--so the fact that the review turned into a big joke at Lincoln's expense is their own fault.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, cp-the-nerd said:


Base MSRP for a 3.0T AWD is $43,735. This is included in the C&D specs I posted and confirmed on Lincoln's website. They shouldn't even offer that engine with FWD, which is what you used (along with incentives) to get it under $40k.

The tire argument is lame to *YOU* because you refuse to see the reality of Car & Driver's comments or anyone else's perspective, for that matter. Ford sent that car--insane options and all--so the fact that the review turned into a big joke at Lincoln's expense is their own fault.

Bingo!

21 hours ago, cp-the-nerd said:

2017-Lincoln-MKZ-3.0T-AWD-101-876x535.jp

 

2017-Lincoln-MKZ-3.0T-AWD-106-876x535.jp

 

2017-Lincoln-MKZ-3.0T-AWD-119-876x535.jp

Can we keep the kind of cool historical looking greenish house in the back ground and send this to IIHS for voluntary crash testing?

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cp-the-nerd    426

I hit $56k MSRP on the configurator by selecting black label, 3.0T/AWD, and picking a paint color that wasn't silver or black. It's a lot easier to push $60k than you'd think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, cp-the-nerd said:

I hit $56k MSRP on the configurator by selecting black label, 3.0T/AWD, and picking a paint color that wasn't silver or black. It's a lot easier to push $60k than you'd think.

And at that price, a whole new world opens up to you.

...and sorry if I seemed unusually harsh in my earlier comments. The existential angst of selling back my TDI is starting to hit home.  Beginning to think there won't be a fix and I do not want to subject my  car to a sad, short life after it leaves my hands.

Also do not really find myself being sold on anything I am looking at for a repalcemnt.  that being said, I really dislike the Lincoln in question in this thread.

 

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Wings4Life(BANNED)    1,000,000

Loading up premium trim interiors and technology packages will radically increase the price of any premium car.

The fact of the matter is, you can get all that power, nicely equipped, and yes with AWD for $44K……and NOTHING can touch it for less.  So put that in your pipe and smoke it.

 

Oh, and the tires are ABSOLUTELY available as well. 

 

So…….

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Drew Dowdell    5,000

On the tire thing.  This is what I was referencing. Edmunds accused Ford of a "ringer" in 2012 by putting .... wait for it.... Michelin Pilot Super Sports on an MKZ for the Press Fleet... an addition that allowed the MKZ to beat an M5 through the slalom. However, while it is correct that the MKZ is technically available with them, less than 1% of MKZs came so equipped. 

So rather than give a realistic view of the car, Lincoln hands the press a Ringer that isn't one based on a technicality. Based on that percentage... it means about 300 MKZs out of the ~34k sold per year are equipped with these tires. 

So really, the review should have the disclaimer "Results not typical".

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Drew Dowdell    5,000
24 minutes ago, Wings4Life said:

So Lincoln put track tires on a car that never sees a track, except for testing.

 

Sounds right to me.  Who cares about percentages.

Because as journalists, our job is to report our findings on cars as people would actually use them.  It's precisely why I got into this business. I would see stupid comparisons of Lincoln Continentals and BMW 5-series in slalom runs... as if 1) Any Lincoln buyer 15 years ago cared about slalom times and 2) Any 5-series buyer was cross shopping a Continental.    Years ago I got mad at Cadillac for sending me an SRX in a configuration that had already been canceled... what's the point of writing a review on a product that people were no longer going to be able to buy?  In the case of this MKZ, what's the point of writing a review (except perhaps as a sidebar) of a vehicle that virtually no one will buy?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cp-the-nerd    426

Don't bother, Drew. He's got the Ford blinders on at full power. We've all made perfectly rational arguments as to why the tires are comically ridiculous, and he just says "Lincoln offers them so it counts."

He read this review like
c4jt321.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ccap41    1,163
22 minutes ago, Drew Dowdell said:

On the tire thing.  This is what I was referencing. Edmunds accused Ford of a "ringer" in 2012 by putting .... wait for it.... Michelin Pilot Super Sports on an MKZ for the Press Fleet...

Very interesting, indeed.

22 minutes ago, Drew Dowdell said:

an addition that allowed the MKZ to beat an M5 through the slalom.

That tire shouldn't make it or break it to an M5.

 

46 minutes ago, Drew Dowdell said:

However, while it is correct that the MKZ is technically available with them, less than 1% of MKZs came so equipped.

I definitely see your point.. but the same can be said when they test near 50k mustangs and Camaros. Very few in owners hands are that loaded up but that's what they get to test because you're showing off the best of the best for the car.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Drew Dowdell    5,000
27 minutes ago, ccap41 said:

Very interesting, indeed.

That tire shouldn't make it or break it to an M5.

 

I definitely see your point.. but the same can be said when they test near 50k mustangs and Camaros. Very few in owners hands are that loaded up but that's what they get to test because you're showing off the best of the best for the car.

Mags generally test Mustangs and Camaros in every available powertrain configuration. While most people do opt of the lesser models... there is a point to reviews of the ZL-1 and GT350 reviews even though only a small percentage of either will be sold.  When you buy a ZL-1 or GT350, you're buying more than just a set of wheels and tires... there are a whole host of upgrades that come with it.   Furthermore, journalists know they are testing some high performance machine.

As for this MKZ, sure it's got 19s on it, but unless you make a habit of noting the sidewall before you get in and drive, there is no reason to expect the car to be any different than what you'll find on a typical dealer's lot. In this case with the MKZ, Lincoln supplied a car in a configuration that virtually no one will buy and attempted to pass it off as normal. Furthermore, the build sticker on the door jam indicated that the car was originally configured with 18s but whoever manages their press fleet decided to swap out the wheels. When you select the high performance tires though, the suspension gets recalibrated to handle it.  This test car didn't have the recalibration...meaning that technically, no, you can't buy this configuration from Lincoln without someone pulling a switcharoo at the dealership.

 And yet... even configured properly, it is highly unlikely that you will find one of these MKZs at a Lincoln dealership. Lincoln is only building about 300 of these cars per year with this tire package.  There are about 325 Lincoln dealerships, so less than one per dealer per year with these tires.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your content will need to be approved by a moderator

Guest
You are commenting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoticons maximum are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Similar Content

    • By William Maley
      FORD F-SERIES SURPASSES THE 70,000 MARK; FORD BRAND SUVS SET RECORD; COMPANY'S OVERALL U.S. SALES DOWN 7.2 PERCENT

    • By Drew Dowdell
      Another big reveal at the 2017 New York Auto Show this year… and we do mean BIG… is the 2018 Lincoln Navigator.  While it technically shares its platform with the new 2018 Ford Expedition that was released at the Chicago Auto Show, the Navigator somehow manages to look bigger.   Up front is a bold and impressive grille that moves the Navigator to the new family face shared by the Lincoln Continental and Lincoln MKZ.  Everything about the exterior is brash. It has giant turbine-look wheels, large fender vents, and full-width LED lights. This is not subtle luxury, yet it pulls off the look without being tacky. This is the new American version of “I’ve Made It”. Cadillac, you have some work cut out for you. 
      The interior is nothing short of stunning. All the materials feel high quality. There may be an excess of buttons (I count 27 on the driver’s door alone), but it’s a Navigator… excess is the whole point. There are available 30 way power seats, be prepared to take a couple hours to get them exactly right, but once you’re there, you won’t want to leave.  If you elect the rear bucket seats, rear seat passengers will have a comfortable ride and have some control over the entertainment system from their own center console. One flaw I found was that in models equipped with rear seat video entertainment, the second row can flip forward and hit the screens when laying the second-row flat…. Not something I expect to happen too often.
      The new Navigator is powered by a 450 horsepower Ecoboost V6 passing power through a new 10 speed automatic to either the rear wheels or an available AWD system. 
      Pricing on the 2018 Navigator hasn’t been released yet, however we expect an appropriate increase over the discount pricing on the 2017 model.
      You can read the full press release information on our 2018 Lincoln Navigator press release page.
       
  • My Clubs

  • Who's Online (See full list)