Everyone take a deep breath. We can do this without rancor if we try (we've done so in the past in "illicit" political threads).
Anyway, this is how I see things.
First, we would have been so much better off if McCain had beaten "W" in the 2000 primary. There is simply no way he would have handled the last eight years as ineptly as Bush has. But that's of no value now.
I've already prepared myself for both outcomes of this election and feel ok with either result as improvement from the current reality will be inevitable.
Now, I am leaning toward McCain for a few reasons. The first being that I have respected the man for years despite the fact that I don't agree with him on many issues. I have watched him handle things in the senate in a rational way and be willing to work toward agreements with all comers. Some of his core ideas thgrough the years have been extremely logical and pragmatic and have moved the entire congress to enact needed legislation (albeit watered down). I see real leadership in his record as well as the tenacity required to get results.
Second, the man's entire life has prepared him for this job. He is likely the most qualified candidate for the office post-Nixon.
Third, I hate the "pendulum swing" of switching from republican to democrat and vice-versa in an environment like we have currently. Both parties waste too much time undoing what the previous party did while in office. The extreme shift from Bush to Obama could easily leave us in a very bad state in my view. I would prefer to see someone with a steadier hand guide us gently away from the madness of the current administration. I think that the nation needs some time to lick its wounds and gather its wits after the last 8 years. I think it is time for a president willing to quietly do the work for a while instead of leading a revolution. In my view, McCain is just such a man. He has a real sense of duty and honor (as corny as that might sound). The man is like a good mechanic - he'll work on what is actually broken. I also believe that we fare better when the congress and the presidency are led by opposing parties as it forces them to work together. And don't judge him by the campaign BS that his party foists on him, nor his somewhat lacking skills as an orator - he is more about doing the job well than scoring points for his speechifying. I guess what I am saying is that McCain has a work ethic about him that I am comfortable with. Especially at this time, and for this office.
Fourth, having seen his conduct within the senate, I believe that he is not constrained by the more extreme factions of his party beyond election day. Once in office, I have seen him operate in a sensible and pragmatic fashion for years and expect no different from him as president.
Fifth, McCain indicated quite a while back that he would only serve a single term. I hope that this remains true because I don't want to see anyone in power for 8 years ever again.
If he confirms this one point, I will vote for him for that reason alone.
Still, I am undecided.
I like Obama.
I like his energy and many of his ideas.
I like the fact that he is of my generation. That fact gives us some common ground that I do not share with McCain.
However, I would rather see him take office in January of 2013.
I guess it is a matter of timing for me.
And I may yet decide that it is best to vote for the future I really want, the sort that a Libertarian would fashion.
Stay tuned.