• Sign in to follow this  
    Followers 0

    Cadillac's Marketing Chief Admits the ELR Price Was A Bit Too Much


    • Uwe Ellinghaus Admits the ELR was priced too high

    You don't hear a lot of executives admit when they or their company has made a blunder. When they do, it comes as a bit of a shock and helps you realize they are somewhat human. Case in point is Cadillac's marketing chief Uwe Ellinghaus telling Bloomberg they bit off bit a more than they could chew with the ELR pricing.

     

    "The MSRP was, indeed, a mouthful. We overestimated that customers would realize our competitors were naked at that price," said Ellinghaus.

     

    So why did Cadillac price the ELR so high? Well product planners believed if the ELR was close to the price of the Chevrolet Volt, people would go for the Volt. Also, the high price was seen as to signal this was a special car from Cadillac.

     

    "We just wanted to make this a statement for the brand of how progressive we are," said Ellinghaus.

     

    Sadly it hasn't worked with just 1,835 ELRs being sold in North America within the past 18 months. Also, dealers have been piling on incentives to get them off their lot.

     

    Source: Bloomberg

    0


    Sign in to follow this  
    Followers 0


    User Feedback




    "The MSRP was, indeed, a mouthful." 

     

    Um, I think potential buyers were more concerned with another bodily orifice when they saw the $75,000.00 price tag.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Also, dealers have been piling on incentives to get them off their lot.

     

     

    Seems we've heard & heard this before....

     

     

    Cort :) www.oldcarsstronghearts.com

    1979 & 1989 Caprice Classics | pigValve, paceMaker, cowValve
    "Promises mean everything" __ Everclear __ 'Wonderful'
    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Call up all the GM, Cadillac, and EV haters because we gotta 'nother live one. Some people love to hear this kinda thing. Its actually a bit weird.

     

    ELR at $75K was fine IF Cadillac only wanted to sell them to niche buyers. They didn't. They FAILED to sell the intended 3000 (last year about 1/2 of that)  units annually because they did nothing to market this car after "Poolside" went viral and let's be honest, its a 2-seater (eff the back seat in any of these sports coupes/Verts from Cadillac to Benz), it has no sunroof, which is insane considering the market for this car would seemingly be the well-to-do, Silicon Valley, greenie types who love to show up in something sexy that lets their hair blow around in the wind. 

     
    This car.. THIS CAR.. should have been a sub-ATS sports car, with a convertible roof or sunroof having coupe, with a TT 2.0L 270HP and 350HP VSeries version, and ta hell with EV. The Voltec should have gone in the XTS. The XTS, with Voltec would have made sense. The XTS with Voltec would have added numbers in the realm of what Tesla sell because it would be in a car that could actually seat 5, maybe 6, with a trunk that could house a bunch of Golf Clubs.
     
    Anyway, the CT6 Hybrid rights this wrong. The ELR, will return in a proper form, and a different name. I'm thinking CT7. The CT6, with 335 hp and 432 lb-ft of torque, not to mention light weight will be pretty refreshing   

    And another thing I wish people would stop always bringing up the Tesla Model S. The comparison of the Tesla Model S to the Cadillac ELR was a dumb one created by idiots in the first place simply because of price and they both being EVs. 

     
    Tesla Model S is a 7-Seater. ELR is a 4 Seater. 
    Tesla Model S is a sedan. ELR is a Coupe
    Tesla Model S is a Full-Sizer. ELR is a Compact
    Tesla Model S is a 100% EV. ELR is a Plug-in Hybrid
     
     
    Lets start comparing Pick-ups to Dirt-Bikes.
    -1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    To top it off, the Model S may sell in steadily, slightly increasing volume, but it still doesn't make the company one thin dime. They have to keep it going because it's the ONLY vehicle they have. Cadillac/GM, of course, have the room to speak on the ELR because it's one of a hundred vehicles built.

     

    Still, these guys don't understand marketing. It's one thing to (appear) candid in an interview, it's another to openly admit 'mistakes'. It gains you nothing.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    No kidding Sherlock, where was the voice of reason when that came to that insane price to begin with.  They missed the opportunity to price it between $55k and $60k.  Cadillac needs to take a page from Lexus of the past and price their cars at a reasonable low price as not to be perceived as low rent.  Then work their way up and people would have been more tolerate of the pricing environment.  I love Gm and  Cadillac but there is a perception problem they have to work around and doing business as usual is not going to make it go away.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This car should have been $49,995 base price, but come fully loaded with no options.  It's a Volt, asking $50k is even stretching.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Perhaps there are some brains at GM, afterall. It was obvious from the beginning that the price was completely unjustified. The funny thing is... A lot of you guys tried to justify it in the beginning. Watching the backpedaling and further attempts of justification is about as good as any C&G movie gets. 

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This car should have been $49,995 base price, but come fully loaded with no options.  It's a Volt, asking $50k is even stretching.

     

     

    Agreed. It does not offer much more either.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    55-60 MSRP would have been fine. The interior is gorgeous as is the exterior. Based on style alone, it would have sold alright out of the box marketed that way.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The ELR interior should have been in the ATS.   Would have made the ATS more competitive.  The ELR wouldn't have sold at anything over $50k, the Volt is a slow seller, a luxury Volt was always going to be an even slower seller.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Perhaps there are some brains at GM, afterall. It was obvious from the beginning that the price was completely unjustified. The funny thing is... A lot of you guys tried to justify it in the beginning. Watching the backpedaling and further attempts of justification is about as good as any C&G movie gets. 

     

     

     

    Please. The technology is sound,.. the packaging was the issue. What exactly justifies the price of any luxury car over a competent mainstream competitor??? Can U really tell me why a 328i is justified in costing $20K more than a Camry???  

     

    I would have sold the ELR for $75K.. I just would have made the ELR a different, more substantial car for the main reason why going green makes since.. in all segments.. to be environmentally friendly. The configuration is wrong. Tesla had another model that was a failure because since when is a two seater environmentally friendly??? Must carry up to 4 Comfortably whether it be a Model S, ELR, or Chevy Tahoe. Yup.. Chevy Tahoe. Fill one up with people and it could be as fuel efficient as a Prius

    -1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The ELR interior should have been in the ATS.   Would have made the ATS more competitive.  The ELR wouldn't have sold at anything over $50k, the Volt is a slow seller, a luxury Volt was always going to be an even slower seller.

     

     

    No it shouldn't have been The ELR has an interior that features materials that make the S-Class seem overpriced. The ATS interior is not the reason for its sales issues. This price point now presented will go a nice way to getting more sales for the ELR. 

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The S-class isn't overpriced, if it were then people would stop buying it.  But it has been the global sales leader for about 40 years, people must think it is a good buy.  Unlike the ELR that will spend about 4 years on market with no sales and be killed off.

     

    The ATS interior doesn't drive away sales, but I don't think it is bringing people in either.  The ATS is a poor seller, it needs something that is a wow factor to bring in more buyers.

    -1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    We've been over this : if the S-class weren't overpriced, it wouldn't need heavy incentives.

    Last gen was sometimes hitting $15 grand off sticker.

     

    ATS physically doesn't need anything glaring or major, it's not the product that's deficient.

    There's also no wow factor from the germans in this segment.

    1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    In most months the S-class outsells its closest 3 competitors COMBINED and at a higher transaction price.  It creates $1 billion a year in profit for Daimler, there are no problems in the cash making department with the S-class.

     

    There is a new A4 coming next year, along with the mild refresh the 3-series, and the Jag XE is coming.  Competition is only increasing.  The ATS doesn't sell now, and they have another 3-4 years in this life cycle.  Dressing up the interior an extra level would help.  I don't see a downside to taking much of the design and materials for the ELR interior and putting it into the ATS which is a similar sized car.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    ATS= fix Cue, fix pricing and packages, new dash but most importantly, give the car some leg room in the back.  The ATS-L body should become the ATS sedan.  American lux car intenders have always wanted some room in their car and the ATS doesn't have enough and it would improve sales if it did.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    In most months the S-class outsells its closest 3 competitors COMBINED and at a higher transaction price.  It creates $1 billion a year in profit for Daimler, there are no problems in the cash making department with the S-class.

     

    There is a new A4 coming next year, along with the mild refresh the 3-series, and the Jag XE is coming.  Competition is only increasing.  The ATS doesn't sell now, and they have another 3-4 years in this life cycle.  Dressing up the interior an extra level would help.  I don't see a downside to taking much of the design and materials for the ELR interior and putting it into the ATS which is a similar sized car.

     

     

     

    U really are delusional. Your argument of sales is ridiculous.. as the Camry outsells several cars in its segment 3:1. The fact that with its numbers.. it generates $1 Billion in profit.. proves my original, and Balthazar's supporting assertion about it being overpriced. That is.. essentially how U make profit. Only a fool would pay full price for an S-Class... when U can get one for about $30K off a year later. I can find U a '13 S550 with 23K miles for under $60K. That's a fact

    Edited by Cmicasa the Great
    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    ATS= fix Cue, fix pricing and packages, new dash but most importantly, give the car some leg room in the back.  The ATS-L body should become the ATS sedan.  American lux car intenders have always wanted some room in their car and the ATS doesn't have enough and it would improve sales if it did.

     

     

     

    I agree about the legroom. Not because I would ever have anymore than 2 people in my sport sedan or hate the idea of chauffeuring anyone... but because apparently more and more people are buying small compact luxury sedans and trying to squeeze their lazy ass friends in the rear to be chauffeured, when they could have just bought a larger CTS..

    Edited by Cmicasa the Great
    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    In most months the S-class outsells its closest 3 competitors COMBINED and at a higher transaction price.  It creates $1 billion a year in profit for Daimler, there are no problems in the cash making department with the S-class.

     

    There is a new A4 coming next year, along with the mild refresh the 3-series, and the Jag XE is coming.  Competition is only increasing.  The ATS doesn't sell now, and they have another 3-4 years in this life cycle.  Dressing up the interior an extra level would help.  I don't see a downside to taking much of the design and materials for the ELR interior and putting it into the ATS which is a similar sized car.

     

     

     

    U really are delusional. Your argument of sales is ridiculous.. as the Camry outsells several cars in its segment 3:1. The fact that with its numbers.. it generates $1 Billion in profit.. proves my original, and Balthazar's supporting assertion about it being overpriced. That is.. essentially how U make profit. Only a fool would pay full price for an S-Class... when U can get one for about $30K off a year later. I can find U a '13 S550 with 23K miles for under $60K. That's a fact

     

    But the Camry doesn't outsell the Accord, Altima and Fusion combined, and cost 20% more than those 3.  If buyers thought the S-class was over priced or a rip off then it wouldn't sell.  S-class has over 40 years on top of the mountain, no one has knocked it off yet.   They have sold about 3 million S-classes since 1972 when they actually started using the S-class name.  There must have been a lot of fools walking into Mercedes dealerships since then.

     

    I am sure the bean counters at GM would have loved if the ELR sold 1,000 units a month at their $75,000 price tag so they turned a profit.   Rather than having almost no sales and having to kill the product off as another one and done.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Jag XE is competition for nobody; no one buys Jags in this country.  

    True, hardly anyone buys a Jag, but they'll sell like 1,000 a month, they will have to steal that off someone.  People bought the X-type and it was terrible.  I don't think it is a big threat either, but it might take 200 cars a month away from Cadillac, BMW, Lexus and Mercedes. 

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    They barely sell 1000 /mnth now with multiple models. XE isn't going to reach anywhere near 1000/mn- there's just no "wow factor" and no one is clamoring for any more Jags. Niche brand, not competition.

    0

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Your content will need to be approved by a moderator

    Guest
    You are commenting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
    Add a comment...

    ×   You have pasted content with formatting.   Remove formatting

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor




  • Popular Stories

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Lloyd-TX
      Lloyd-TX
      (62 years old)
  • Similar Content

    • By William Maley
      In 2009, Cadillac was gearing up to launch the brand in Australia. A small number of dealers had signed up to begin selling a right-hand drive version of CTS. But weeks before the launch, plans were axed. The economic crisis and fluctuations in various currencies were the reasons given. But in the past couple of years, various GM executives have said the brand will be coming to Australia and pictures have surfaced of various Cadillac models in the country. 
      However, head of General Motors International Stefan Jacoby poured a bucket of cold water on this, telling Australian media at the Detroit Auto Show that the time isn't right for Cadillac to enter Australia.
      "We have no plans for that," said Jacoby.
      "First of all we should manage Holden and then we should look to Cadillac."
      Holden is currently transitioning from relying heavily on the Commodore to expanding their lineup comprised of vehicles coming from around the world. Already, Holden has launched the Astra Hatchback and will soon be launching the Astra sedan (Chevrolet Cruze) and Acadia. Once Holden is successful with this, Jacoby said they would revisit the idea of Cadillac in Australia.
      Cadillac chief designer Andrew Smith (who happens to be a Holden alum) tells Drive.com.au that he would like to see Cadillacs on Australian roads, but only when the time is right.

      "We're talking about Cadillac in Australia and I see it as a really good fit, but it is a futile exercise until you have exactly the portfolio you need," said Smith.
      "I think the Australian market is an interesting one, it's always been a mix of the European market and the American tastes. Even though we like to think it is European certainly American tastes are similar. But again it's about having everything we need to make sure we can launch it properly."
      Source: Drive.com.au

      View full article
    • By William Maley
      In 2009, Cadillac was gearing up to launch the brand in Australia. A small number of dealers had signed up to begin selling a right-hand drive version of CTS. But weeks before the launch, plans were axed. The economic crisis and fluctuations in various currencies were the reasons given. But in the past couple of years, various GM executives have said the brand will be coming to Australia and pictures have surfaced of various Cadillac models in the country. 
      However, head of General Motors International Stefan Jacoby poured a bucket of cold water on this, telling Australian media at the Detroit Auto Show that the time isn't right for Cadillac to enter Australia.
      "We have no plans for that," said Jacoby.
      "First of all we should manage Holden and then we should look to Cadillac."
      Holden is currently transitioning from relying heavily on the Commodore to expanding their lineup comprised of vehicles coming from around the world. Already, Holden has launched the Astra Hatchback and will soon be launching the Astra sedan (Chevrolet Cruze) and Acadia. Once Holden is successful with this, Jacoby said they would revisit the idea of Cadillac in Australia.
      Cadillac chief designer Andrew Smith (who happens to be a Holden alum) tells Drive.com.au that he would like to see Cadillacs on Australian roads, but only when the time is right.

      "We're talking about Cadillac in Australia and I see it as a really good fit, but it is a futile exercise until you have exactly the portfolio you need," said Smith.
      "I think the Australian market is an interesting one, it's always been a mix of the European market and the American tastes. Even though we like to think it is European certainly American tastes are similar. But again it's about having everything we need to make sure we can launch it properly."
      Source: Drive.com.au
    • By William Maley
      Are you one of those people who can't seem to decide if they want a sports sedan or a luxury crossover? Then listen up as Cadillac has announced something you might be interested in.
      Next month, Cadillac will be launching 'Book by Cadillac' for the New York Metro Area. For $1,500 a month, members will be able to choose from Cadillac's Platinum trim and V-Series lineup. This is done through a smartphone app where a member can request a vehicle. From there, a concierge will drop off your selected vehicle to your requested location. Vehicles can be kept for as long as a member wants and can be easily swapped. 
      The $1,500 monthly fee covers insurance, registration, and maintenance of the vehicle.
      Cadillac plans on launching Book into other markets down the road.
      Source: Cadillac
      Press Release is on Page 2


      Introducing BOOK by Cadillac, a Bold New Luxury Vehicle Subscription Model
      Rather than owning a single vehicle, members can switch between different Cadillacs to best suit their needs with this first-of-its-kind subscription service from an OEM. NEW YORK — Cadillac is continuing to push the boundaries of the driving experience with a first-of-its kind luxury vehicle subscription service, BOOK by Cadillac. For a flat monthly fee, BOOK by Cadillac gives members access to popular Cadillac vehicles without the commitment of leasing, financing or buying.
      “BOOK by Cadillac is an innovative new option targeted at a growing class of luxury drivers searching for access to various cars over time, dependent on their individual needs, coupled with a hassle-free white-glove exchange,” said Uwe Ellinghaus, Cadillac chief marketing officer.
      BOOK by Cadillac members will have app-enabled on-demand access to the latest premium trim Cadillac models to keep in their possession. The vehicles will be delivered via white-glove concierge to members’ requested locations and exchanged at their leisure or as their needs change. Members can just as easily take to the winding roads in a performance V Series and enjoy a back-mountain winter ski trip in an Escalade in the same week. Alternatively, they can keep an SUV during the winter months and switch to a performance sedan during the summer, with each vehicle picked up and delivered to their doorstep.
      With maintenance, insurance and detailing of the vehicle handled by Cadillac, members are freed from the baggage that comes with traditional vehicle ownership and given the freedom and flexibility to fit their lifestyle.
      BOOK by Cadillac will launch first in the New York metro area, with plans to debut in other markets. 
      The Details:
      A flat monthly fee of $1,500 eliminates the hassles of car ownership so members can experience uninhibited driving. Membership is month-to-month with no long-term commitment required. Members can use a mobile app to reserve vehicles that will be delivered to their specified locations via a white-glove concierge service. Certain location restrictions apply. Members will have access to the current year Platinum Level Trim Cadillacs, including the XT5, CT6, Escalade and V Series. Registration, taxes, insurance and maintenance costs are included in the monthly rate and there is no limit on mileage.
      Other fees may apply. For detailed information on all the benefits of membership and how to join, please visit www.BOOKByCadillac.com.

      View full article
    • By William Maley
      Are you one of those people who can't seem to decide if they want a sports sedan or a luxury crossover? Then listen up as Cadillac has announced something you might be interested in.
      Next month, Cadillac will be launching 'Book by Cadillac' for the New York Metro Area. For $1,500 a month, members will be able to choose from Cadillac's Platinum trim and V-Series lineup. This is done through a smartphone app where a member can request a vehicle. From there, a concierge will drop off your selected vehicle to your requested location. Vehicles can be kept for as long as a member wants and can be easily swapped. 
      The $1,500 monthly fee covers insurance, registration, and maintenance of the vehicle.
      Cadillac plans on launching Book into other markets down the road.
      Source: Cadillac
      Press Release is on Page 2


      Introducing BOOK by Cadillac, a Bold New Luxury Vehicle Subscription Model
      Rather than owning a single vehicle, members can switch between different Cadillacs to best suit their needs with this first-of-its-kind subscription service from an OEM. NEW YORK — Cadillac is continuing to push the boundaries of the driving experience with a first-of-its kind luxury vehicle subscription service, BOOK by Cadillac. For a flat monthly fee, BOOK by Cadillac gives members access to popular Cadillac vehicles without the commitment of leasing, financing or buying.
      “BOOK by Cadillac is an innovative new option targeted at a growing class of luxury drivers searching for access to various cars over time, dependent on their individual needs, coupled with a hassle-free white-glove exchange,” said Uwe Ellinghaus, Cadillac chief marketing officer.
      BOOK by Cadillac members will have app-enabled on-demand access to the latest premium trim Cadillac models to keep in their possession. The vehicles will be delivered via white-glove concierge to members’ requested locations and exchanged at their leisure or as their needs change. Members can just as easily take to the winding roads in a performance V Series and enjoy a back-mountain winter ski trip in an Escalade in the same week. Alternatively, they can keep an SUV during the winter months and switch to a performance sedan during the summer, with each vehicle picked up and delivered to their doorstep.
      With maintenance, insurance and detailing of the vehicle handled by Cadillac, members are freed from the baggage that comes with traditional vehicle ownership and given the freedom and flexibility to fit their lifestyle.
      BOOK by Cadillac will launch first in the New York metro area, with plans to debut in other markets. 
      The Details:
      A flat monthly fee of $1,500 eliminates the hassles of car ownership so members can experience uninhibited driving. Membership is month-to-month with no long-term commitment required. Members can use a mobile app to reserve vehicles that will be delivered to their specified locations via a white-glove concierge service. Certain location restrictions apply. Members will have access to the current year Platinum Level Trim Cadillacs, including the XT5, CT6, Escalade and V Series. Registration, taxes, insurance and maintenance costs are included in the monthly rate and there is no limit on mileage.
      Other fees may apply. For detailed information on all the benefits of membership and how to join, please visit www.BOOKByCadillac.com.
    • By William Maley
      As a number of manufacturers are running away from diesel (and who can blame them), Chevrolet is running towards it with the introduction of the Cruze Diesel early next year. Now Chevrolet has announced pricing for the diesel variant.
      The Cruze Diesel will begin at $24,670 for the six-speed manual and $26,270 for the nine-speed automatic. Like the previous Cruze Diesel, the new model will only be available in the LT trim which nets you LED daytime running lights, seven-inch infotainment system, and six-speaker audio system. The diesel will also get the optional Convenience package as standard - keyless entry, push-button start, power driver's seat, and heat for the front seats. 
      In terms of options, a leather package for $1,125 is available for both transmissions. The automatic also gets the option of the Sun/Sound/Confidence package. The 'too many words for a name' package adds a Bose nine-speaker audio system, an 8-inch infotainment system, a color screen for the trip computer, power sunroof, blind-spot monitoring, rear parking sensors, and rear cross-traffic alert. This package adds $3,680.
      It should be noted this pricing is for the sedan. The Cruze Diesel hatchback isn't due till 2018.
      Source: Car and Driver, Roadshow
      Pic Credit: William Maley for Cheers & Gears

      View full article
  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

    There are no registered users currently online