Jump to content
  • William Maley
    William Maley

    Cadillac's Marketing Chief Admits the ELR Price Was A Bit Too Much

    Sign in to follow this  

      Uwe Ellinghaus Admits the ELR was priced too high

    You don't hear a lot of executives admit when they or their company has made a blunder. When they do, it comes as a bit of a shock and helps you realize they are somewhat human. Case in point is Cadillac's marketing chief Uwe Ellinghaus telling Bloomberg they bit off bit a more than they could chew with the ELR pricing.

     

    "The MSRP was, indeed, a mouthful. We overestimated that customers would realize our competitors were naked at that price," said Ellinghaus.

     

    So why did Cadillac price the ELR so high? Well product planners believed if the ELR was close to the price of the Chevrolet Volt, people would go for the Volt. Also, the high price was seen as to signal this was a special car from Cadillac.

     

    "We just wanted to make this a statement for the brand of how progressive we are," said Ellinghaus.

     

    Sadly it hasn't worked with just 1,835 ELRs being sold in North America within the past 18 months. Also, dealers have been piling on incentives to get them off their lot.

     

    Source: Bloomberg

    Sign in to follow this  


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    "The MSRP was, indeed, a mouthful." 

     

    Um, I think potential buyers were more concerned with another bodily orifice when they saw the $75,000.00 price tag.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Also, dealers have been piling on incentives to get them off their lot.

     

     

    Seems we've heard & heard this before....

     

     

    Cort :) www.oldcarsstronghearts.com

    1979 & 1989 Caprice Classics | pigValve, paceMaker, cowValve
    "Promises mean everything" __ Everclear __ 'Wonderful'

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Call up all the GM, Cadillac, and EV haters because we gotta 'nother live one. Some people love to hear this kinda thing. Its actually a bit weird.

     

    ELR at $75K was fine IF Cadillac only wanted to sell them to niche buyers. They didn't. They FAILED to sell the intended 3000 (last year about 1/2 of that)  units annually because they did nothing to market this car after "Poolside" went viral and let's be honest, its a 2-seater (eff the back seat in any of these sports coupes/Verts from Cadillac to Benz), it has no sunroof, which is insane considering the market for this car would seemingly be the well-to-do, Silicon Valley, greenie types who love to show up in something sexy that lets their hair blow around in the wind. 

     
    This car.. THIS CAR.. should have been a sub-ATS sports car, with a convertible roof or sunroof having coupe, with a TT 2.0L 270HP and 350HP VSeries version, and ta hell with EV. The Voltec should have gone in the XTS. The XTS, with Voltec would have made sense. The XTS with Voltec would have added numbers in the realm of what Tesla sell because it would be in a car that could actually seat 5, maybe 6, with a trunk that could house a bunch of Golf Clubs.
     
    Anyway, the CT6 Hybrid rights this wrong. The ELR, will return in a proper form, and a different name. I'm thinking CT7. The CT6, with 335 hp and 432 lb-ft of torque, not to mention light weight will be pretty refreshing   

    And another thing I wish people would stop always bringing up the Tesla Model S. The comparison of the Tesla Model S to the Cadillac ELR was a dumb one created by idiots in the first place simply because of price and they both being EVs. 

     
    Tesla Model S is a 7-Seater. ELR is a 4 Seater. 
    Tesla Model S is a sedan. ELR is a Coupe
    Tesla Model S is a Full-Sizer. ELR is a Compact
    Tesla Model S is a 100% EV. ELR is a Plug-in Hybrid
     
     
    Lets start comparing Pick-ups to Dirt-Bikes.
    • Downvote 1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    To top it off, the Model S may sell in steadily, slightly increasing volume, but it still doesn't make the company one thin dime. They have to keep it going because it's the ONLY vehicle they have. Cadillac/GM, of course, have the room to speak on the ELR because it's one of a hundred vehicles built.

     

    Still, these guys don't understand marketing. It's one thing to (appear) candid in an interview, it's another to openly admit 'mistakes'. It gains you nothing.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    No kidding Sherlock, where was the voice of reason when that came to that insane price to begin with.  They missed the opportunity to price it between $55k and $60k.  Cadillac needs to take a page from Lexus of the past and price their cars at a reasonable low price as not to be perceived as low rent.  Then work their way up and people would have been more tolerate of the pricing environment.  I love Gm and  Cadillac but there is a perception problem they have to work around and doing business as usual is not going to make it go away.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This car should have been $49,995 base price, but come fully loaded with no options.  It's a Volt, asking $50k is even stretching.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Perhaps there are some brains at GM, afterall. It was obvious from the beginning that the price was completely unjustified. The funny thing is... A lot of you guys tried to justify it in the beginning. Watching the backpedaling and further attempts of justification is about as good as any C&G movie gets. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This car should have been $49,995 base price, but come fully loaded with no options.  It's a Volt, asking $50k is even stretching.

     

     

    Agreed. It does not offer much more either.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    55-60 MSRP would have been fine. The interior is gorgeous as is the exterior. Based on style alone, it would have sold alright out of the box marketed that way.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The ELR interior should have been in the ATS.   Would have made the ATS more competitive.  The ELR wouldn't have sold at anything over $50k, the Volt is a slow seller, a luxury Volt was always going to be an even slower seller.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Perhaps there are some brains at GM, afterall. It was obvious from the beginning that the price was completely unjustified. The funny thing is... A lot of you guys tried to justify it in the beginning. Watching the backpedaling and further attempts of justification is about as good as any C&G movie gets. 

     

     

     

    Please. The technology is sound,.. the packaging was the issue. What exactly justifies the price of any luxury car over a competent mainstream competitor??? Can U really tell me why a 328i is justified in costing $20K more than a Camry???  

     

    I would have sold the ELR for $75K.. I just would have made the ELR a different, more substantial car for the main reason why going green makes since.. in all segments.. to be environmentally friendly. The configuration is wrong. Tesla had another model that was a failure because since when is a two seater environmentally friendly??? Must carry up to 4 Comfortably whether it be a Model S, ELR, or Chevy Tahoe. Yup.. Chevy Tahoe. Fill one up with people and it could be as fuel efficient as a Prius

    • Downvote 1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The ELR interior should have been in the ATS.   Would have made the ATS more competitive.  The ELR wouldn't have sold at anything over $50k, the Volt is a slow seller, a luxury Volt was always going to be an even slower seller.

     

     

    No it shouldn't have been The ELR has an interior that features materials that make the S-Class seem overpriced. The ATS interior is not the reason for its sales issues. This price point now presented will go a nice way to getting more sales for the ELR. 

    • Upvote 1
    • Downvote 1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The S-class isn't overpriced, if it were then people would stop buying it.  But it has been the global sales leader for about 40 years, people must think it is a good buy.  Unlike the ELR that will spend about 4 years on market with no sales and be killed off.

     

    The ATS interior doesn't drive away sales, but I don't think it is bringing people in either.  The ATS is a poor seller, it needs something that is a wow factor to bring in more buyers.

    • Downvote 1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    We've been over this : if the S-class weren't overpriced, it wouldn't need heavy incentives.

    Last gen was sometimes hitting $15 grand off sticker.

     

    ATS physically doesn't need anything glaring or major, it's not the product that's deficient.

    There's also no wow factor from the germans in this segment.

    • Upvote 1

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    In most months the S-class outsells its closest 3 competitors COMBINED and at a higher transaction price.  It creates $1 billion a year in profit for Daimler, there are no problems in the cash making department with the S-class.

     

    There is a new A4 coming next year, along with the mild refresh the 3-series, and the Jag XE is coming.  Competition is only increasing.  The ATS doesn't sell now, and they have another 3-4 years in this life cycle.  Dressing up the interior an extra level would help.  I don't see a downside to taking much of the design and materials for the ELR interior and putting it into the ATS which is a similar sized car.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    ATS= fix Cue, fix pricing and packages, new dash but most importantly, give the car some leg room in the back.  The ATS-L body should become the ATS sedan.  American lux car intenders have always wanted some room in their car and the ATS doesn't have enough and it would improve sales if it did.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    In most months the S-class outsells its closest 3 competitors COMBINED and at a higher transaction price.  It creates $1 billion a year in profit for Daimler, there are no problems in the cash making department with the S-class.

     

    There is a new A4 coming next year, along with the mild refresh the 3-series, and the Jag XE is coming.  Competition is only increasing.  The ATS doesn't sell now, and they have another 3-4 years in this life cycle.  Dressing up the interior an extra level would help.  I don't see a downside to taking much of the design and materials for the ELR interior and putting it into the ATS which is a similar sized car.

     

     

     

    U really are delusional. Your argument of sales is ridiculous.. as the Camry outsells several cars in its segment 3:1. The fact that with its numbers.. it generates $1 Billion in profit.. proves my original, and Balthazar's supporting assertion about it being overpriced. That is.. essentially how U make profit. Only a fool would pay full price for an S-Class... when U can get one for about $30K off a year later. I can find U a '13 S550 with 23K miles for under $60K. That's a fact

    Edited by Cmicasa the Great

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    ATS= fix Cue, fix pricing and packages, new dash but most importantly, give the car some leg room in the back.  The ATS-L body should become the ATS sedan.  American lux car intenders have always wanted some room in their car and the ATS doesn't have enough and it would improve sales if it did.

     

     

     

    I agree about the legroom. Not because I would ever have anymore than 2 people in my sport sedan or hate the idea of chauffeuring anyone... but because apparently more and more people are buying small compact luxury sedans and trying to squeeze their lazy ass friends in the rear to be chauffeured, when they could have just bought a larger CTS..

    Edited by Cmicasa the Great

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    In most months the S-class outsells its closest 3 competitors COMBINED and at a higher transaction price.  It creates $1 billion a year in profit for Daimler, there are no problems in the cash making department with the S-class.

     

    There is a new A4 coming next year, along with the mild refresh the 3-series, and the Jag XE is coming.  Competition is only increasing.  The ATS doesn't sell now, and they have another 3-4 years in this life cycle.  Dressing up the interior an extra level would help.  I don't see a downside to taking much of the design and materials for the ELR interior and putting it into the ATS which is a similar sized car.

     

     

     

    U really are delusional. Your argument of sales is ridiculous.. as the Camry outsells several cars in its segment 3:1. The fact that with its numbers.. it generates $1 Billion in profit.. proves my original, and Balthazar's supporting assertion about it being overpriced. That is.. essentially how U make profit. Only a fool would pay full price for an S-Class... when U can get one for about $30K off a year later. I can find U a '13 S550 with 23K miles for under $60K. That's a fact

     

    But the Camry doesn't outsell the Accord, Altima and Fusion combined, and cost 20% more than those 3.  If buyers thought the S-class was over priced or a rip off then it wouldn't sell.  S-class has over 40 years on top of the mountain, no one has knocked it off yet.   They have sold about 3 million S-classes since 1972 when they actually started using the S-class name.  There must have been a lot of fools walking into Mercedes dealerships since then.

     

    I am sure the bean counters at GM would have loved if the ELR sold 1,000 units a month at their $75,000 price tag so they turned a profit.   Rather than having almost no sales and having to kill the product off as another one and done.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Jag XE is competition for nobody; no one buys Jags in this country.  

    True, hardly anyone buys a Jag, but they'll sell like 1,000 a month, they will have to steal that off someone.  People bought the X-type and it was terrible.  I don't think it is a big threat either, but it might take 200 cars a month away from Cadillac, BMW, Lexus and Mercedes. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    They barely sell 1000 /mnth now with multiple models. XE isn't going to reach anywhere near 1000/mn- there's just no "wow factor" and no one is clamoring for any more Jags. Niche brand, not competition.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Similar Content

    • By William Maley
      Cadillac's Super Cruise system is getting a major upgrade just in time for the 2021 CT4 and CT5. The system will now be able to automatically change lanes whenever the driver taps or fully engages the turn signal stalk. The vehicle will signal and look for a safe gap before making the maneuver. Information as to which step the system is on is shown to driver in the instrument cluster.
      “This is our most extensive update we’ve made to Super Cruise since its debut. We have made a number of improvements to make Super Cruise more intuitive, better performing and more accessible for our customers. In addition to the automated lane change functionality, we’ve made improvements to the user interface and hands-free driving dynamics,”  said Mario Maiorana, Super Cruise chief engineer in a statement.
      This upgrade is due in part to GM's new digital vehicle platform that allows for more "electrical bandwidth and data processing power." Other improvements include better rear-facing sensors and updated software.
      Following the CT4 and CT5, the updated Super Cruise system will appear on the upcoming 2021 Escalade. That brings us to an interesting item caught by the folks at Roadshow. The picture Cadillac used in the press release has the rear end of the next-generation model expected to debut next month.

      Source: Cadillac, Roadshow
      Press Release is on Page 2

      View full article
    • By William Maley
      Cadillac's Super Cruise system is getting a major upgrade just in time for the 2021 CT4 and CT5. The system will now be able to automatically change lanes whenever the driver taps or fully engages the turn signal stalk. The vehicle will signal and look for a safe gap before making the maneuver. Information as to which step the system is on is shown to driver in the instrument cluster.
      “This is our most extensive update we’ve made to Super Cruise since its debut. We have made a number of improvements to make Super Cruise more intuitive, better performing and more accessible for our customers. In addition to the automated lane change functionality, we’ve made improvements to the user interface and hands-free driving dynamics,”  said Mario Maiorana, Super Cruise chief engineer in a statement.
      This upgrade is due in part to GM's new digital vehicle platform that allows for more "electrical bandwidth and data processing power." Other improvements include better rear-facing sensors and updated software.
      Following the CT4 and CT5, the updated Super Cruise system will appear on the upcoming 2021 Escalade. That brings us to an interesting item caught by the folks at Roadshow. The picture Cadillac used in the press release has the rear end of the next-generation model expected to debut next month.

      Source: Cadillac, Roadshow
      Press Release is on Page 2
    • By Drew Dowdell
      QUARTER 4 (CALENDAR YEAR-TO-DATE) JANUARY - DECEMBER   2019 2018 %Change Volume   2019 2018 %Change Volume   Cascada 77 743 -89.6   2,535 4,136 -38.7   Enclave 10,143 14,420 -29.7   51,156 49,647 3.0   Encore 28,497 23,326 22.2   102,402 93,073 10.0   Envision 8,380 7,535 11.2   33,229 30,152 10.2   LaCrosse 463 2,118 -78.1   7,241 15,527 -53.4   Regal 1,514 3,110 -51.3   10,363 14,118 -26.6   Buick Total 49,074 51,257 -4.3   206,929 206,863 0.0   ATS 83 831 -90.0   1,134 10,859 -89.6   CT5 43 0 ***.*   43 0 ***.*   CT6 2,276 2,398 -5.1   7,951 9,668 -17.8   CTS 966 2,442 -60.4   6,965 11,219 -37.9   Escalade 8,889 9,573 -7.1   35,424 36,872 -3.9   XT4 8,895 7,573 17.5   31,987 7,785 310.9   XT5 11,168 13,582 -17.8   49,879 60,565 -17.6   XT6 7,169 0 ***.*   11,559 0 ***.*   XTS 1,062 5,063 -79.0   11,304 17,727 -36.2   Cadillac Total 40,551 41,462 -2.2   156,246 154,702 1.0   Blazer 23,008 27 ***.*   58,115 27 ***.*   Bolt EV 3,307 6,212 -46.8   16,418 18,019 -8.9   Camaro 11,474 11,135 3.0   48,265 50,963 -5.3   Colorado 25,484 30,004 -15.1   122,304 134,842 -9.3   Corvette 3,491 3,910 -10.7   17,988 18,791 -4.3   Cruze 2,699 32,955 -91.8   47,975 142,617 -66.4   Equinox 92,092 98,239 -6.3   346,048 332,618 4.0   Express 16,652 22,543 -26.1   77,457 81,239 -4.7   Impala 9,545 12,604 -24.3   44,978 56,556 -20.5   LCF 1,273 940 35.4   4,495 2,810 60.0   Malibu 34,314 37,084 -7.5   131,917 144,542 -8.7   Silverado HD 36,704 34,222 7.3   131,953 142,632 -7.5   Silverado LD 124,619 126,950 -1.8   438,686 442,943 -1.0   Silverado MD 2,018 6 ***.*   4,961 6 ***.*   Sonic 3,339 2,765 20.8   13,971 20,613 -32.2   Spark 11,016 5,174 112.9   31,281 23,602 32.5   Suburban 10,242 15,200 -32.6   51,928 60,633 -14.4   Tahoe 21,086 24,679 -14.6   101,189 104,153 -2.8   Traverse 33,631 39,536 -14.9   147,122 146,534 0.4   Trax 33,039 22,378 47.6   116,816 89,916 29.9   Volt 370 5,063 -92.7   4,910 18,306 -73.2   Chevrolet Total 499,404 531,985 -6.1   1,958,925 2,036,023 -3.8   Acadia 19,471 25,128 -22.5   99,429 88,621 12.2   Canyon 6,525 8,219 -20.6   32,825 33,492 -2.0   Savana 3,136 2,905 8.0   24,226 19,684 23.1   Sierra HD 18,228 16,550 10.1   59,871 60,389 -0.9   Sierra LD 50,494 50,762 -0.5   172,452 159,165 8.3   Terrain 28,060 31,595 -11.2   101,470 114,314 -11.2   Yukon 20,966 25,366 -17.3   74,673 80,784 -7.6   GMC Total 146,880 160,525 -8.5   564,946 556,449 1.5   GM Vehicle Total* 735,909 785,229 -6.3   2,887,046 2,954,037 -2.3                     78 selling days for the QUARTER 4 this year and 77 for same QUARTER last year.  
    • By Drew Dowdell
      Cadillac President Steve Carlisle said that when Cadillac starts rolling out its electric vehicles, it will use actual words for model names instead of the alphanumeric scheme currently used on its cars and SUVs.  Cadillac's move away from names started in 2003 with the Cadillac CTS. Over time, the Seville and Deville were converted to STS and DTS respectively. Later, the scheme was changed to alphanumeric when Johan de Nysschen joined the company as President.
      Cadillac will be taking the lead on GM's push to introduce 20 new all-electric vehicles around the globe by 2023.  Carlisle said that by 2030, the majority, if not all, Cadillacs will be battery electric vehicles. The recently release set of vehicles, CT4, CT5, XT4, and XT5, will get one more round of refreshes before transitioning to a BEV platform late in the decade. 
      The next introduction is the Cadillac Escalade, which will be officially introduced in February, though pictures of the 2021 Escalade have already leaked online. Cadillac's SuperCruise hands-free driver-assist system will eventually be offered on the Escalade with additional functionality not currently included in the system. There are strong hints that this version of SuperCruise will include lane change ability.

      View full article
    • By Drew Dowdell
      Cadillac President Steve Carlisle said that when Cadillac starts rolling out its electric vehicles, it will use actual words for model names instead of the alphanumeric scheme currently used on its cars and SUVs.  Cadillac's move away from names started in 2003 with the Cadillac CTS. Over time, the Seville and Deville were converted to STS and DTS respectively. Later, the scheme was changed to alphanumeric when Johan de Nysschen joined the company as President.
      Cadillac will be taking the lead on GM's push to introduce 20 new all-electric vehicles around the globe by 2023.  Carlisle said that by 2030, the majority, if not all, Cadillacs will be battery electric vehicles. The recently release set of vehicles, CT4, CT5, XT4, and XT5, will get one more round of refreshes before transitioning to a BEV platform late in the decade. 
      The next introduction is the Cadillac Escalade, which will be officially introduced in February, though pictures of the 2021 Escalade have already leaked online. Cadillac's SuperCruise hands-free driver-assist system will eventually be offered on the Escalade with additional functionality not currently included in the system. There are strong hints that this version of SuperCruise will include lane change ability.
  • Posts

  • Social Stream

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. faithlakemper
      faithlakemper
      (20 years old)
    2. gprix
      gprix
      (73 years old)
  • Who's Online (See full list)

    There are no registered users currently online

  • My Clubs

About us

CheersandGears.com - Founded 2001

We ♥ Cars

Get in touch

Follow us

Recent tweets

facebook

×
×
  • Create New...