I finally received my copy of MT today so I was able to read the entire COTY section and make a decision, not just some knee-jerk reactionary statement I had before. Funny thing is, though, that knee-jerk reaction was right.
First, it seems as if the editors picked the Civic to be COTY even before they started looking for the cars to take part in the competition. "Ok, we're picking the Civic so now what cars can we throw in to try to make it look fair?" You read the reviews for the majority of the competition and it's like they were either looking at/driving the wrong cars or they didn't look at/drive them at all.
Second, I'm surprised MT didn't pick the Hyundai Azera as COTY, though they pretty much made it clear it came in 2nd place. In fact, the editors seemed to get off on all the Korean products, swooning over them like they're God's gifts to the world. I'm sorry but the Azera's interior it NOT luxury-level stuff. According to MT, Buick should be worried more about the Azera than Lexus. I wonder how much the Koreans paid MT?
Third, what they said about Detroit's products was disgusting. You guys know I'm no kool-aid drinker but I was irritated with the comments being made towards everything from the Fusion to the Solstice. The humping order seemed to go like this: Korean (minus the Civic), Japanese, European, American.
In case you guys didn't care like reading or couldn't read the praise given to the Civic, here are some excerpts:
"Indicated redline on the Si's tach is 8000 rpm. The limiter doesn't kick in until 8500 rpm. The engine feels like it would happily spin to 10,000. Sure you could gun a Cobalt SS or Focus ZX4 ST to 8500 rpm. Once."
"Is it just us or does the Si's bizarrely contoured steering wheel...somehow remind you of the mask in "Scream?"
"A cockpit from 'Star Trek' - and it works." (Followed by long paragraph of why it's beautiful)
"These new Civics are rolling artwork."
"Easiest speedo on the market to read."
Who else wants to throw up? My subscription's done and if you want to call me a "baby" or harrass me for it, go ahead. The Civic's minivan-style windshield wipers are calling your name.